Swords into Plowshares

On December 20th, 2008, I turned eighteen. United States law demands that every male between 18 and 25 register for the Selective Service (aka the draft). This was my 'civic duty'.
I am a pacifist.
I believe that participation in war is essentially incompatible with an attempt to emulate the example of Jesus Christ. Jesus says, 'Blessed are the peacemakers' and 'Love your enemies' and 'Turn the other cheek'. He lived this out in radical subservience (but not obedience) to 'authority', spreading a message that ultimately undermines temporal power; for, to quote N. T. Wright, if Jesus is Lord, then Caesar is not. And Jesus, a King who knows no borders, rules over a Kingdom that exists most fully at the margins of empire
Thus I am a pacifist.
Many will say that nonviolence is not 'practical', not 'realistic'. But the Resurrection of Jesus Christ from his grave after a death by crucifixion was not practical, not realistic. My hope, my life, is in that resurrection. Christ's resurrection renders the impossible, possible; the fantastic, realistic; the idealistic, pragmatic.
My faith in nonviolence is not a blind one. It is shared by people of many faiths (such as Ghandi), and backed by scholars who ground it in non-religious research (such as Gene Sharp). Nonviolence is increasingly gaining credibility as an alternative to warfare, killing, and destruction.
Thus, I am a pacifist.
So my obligation to register with the Selective Service proved to be a moral quandary. I cannot kill. But I was required to enroll in a system that could ask me to. So I did some research, and stumbled across the Center on Conscience and War. There I learned that though there is no way to register with the Service as a conscientious objector, many young men do choose to write in their opposition to war on their registration cards.
As I prayed and thought about this process further, I remembered the words of the prophet Micah: 'They shall beat their swords into plowshares, and their spears into pruning hooks; nation shall not rise up against nation, neither shall they learn war any more' (Micah 4.3-4). The Selective Service registration card is a sword. But I could feel God's guidance, that when my time came to fill in that card, to wield that sword, I could beat it into a plowshare.
So yesterday I went to the Post Office. I asked for a card, and took it home. I filled it out. But in a blank space, I wrote: 'I am a conscientious objector to war because of my faith'. In another blank space: 'Love your enemies, and pray for those who persecute you.' On the back: 'Blessed are the peacemakers, for they shall be called children of God', and 'They shall beat their swords into plowshares'. I prayed and mailed it.
Merely symbolic? Perhaps. Meaningless? No.
I hope the empire likes plowshares.
- Matt Shafer's blog
- Login or register to post comments

Comments
Thanks..
Thanks for the feedback, everyone. I appreciate it, being new around here. I definitely plan to keep posting.
Also, I have fixed the link at the bottom of the post.
Plowshares
Hey Matt!
Good job, symbolic or not. I guess things have changed, as I was registered as a CO in the late sixties, requested and was granted that status. I was assisted by The Friends, Quakers, I believe. Had an anti-war counselor &/or advisor & a file with the the FBI. When the CO status was granted I came clean & requested a 4F based on sexual orientation. Had to go through two psychs & my father's harsh judgement, but I didn't believe in the war or killing & opted not to participate in the military. I do believe in public service & was involved in Americorp*VISTA assisting the homeless.
You should enjoy XLeft, I look for to the discussions every evening. Keep up the good fight!
Right, Matt
Thanks for posting. Welcome. Hope you'll stay and write more.
Despite it not being a question of condemning or disrespecting those who serve in the military, I can't reconcile Jesus and war. A while back, in an exchange with Steve about Nader and other issues, I posted a comment with the title Disagreement #1-Nader and never got back to following it up with "Disagreement #2". Disagreement #2 would have been on war: Steve wrote in favor of the use of force at some times, citing Afghanistan and Darfur.
I think we should start a discussion on the Just War Theory in the New Year that's now 38 minutes away.
Peace,
Bill
just war...
I think an ongoing conversation on Just War theory would be great. I have a lot of respect for the theory..it's just that I happen to think that Just Wars are in fact impossible, because of collateral damage, etc.
courageous Matt
Hi Matt,
First welcome to CrossLeft. I hope you can figure us out and make CL an online home for yourself.
I think your stand was courageous. Its not difficult to be a pacifist in our society although there is proud tradition within Christianity and indeed many other faiths of pacifism.
I think in general, we ought to acknowledge that there are many forms of public service. We owe a great debt of gratitude to our men and women in the armed services and we hope that the next President will be much wiser about using force than our last President. For young people though there are other forms of service such as Americorps and Peace Corps which also do a great service to our nation. Perhaps that type of service would be better suited for you. I did a year of Americorps serving in an inner city school in West Philly after college. It was one of the best experiences of my life and I wouldn't trade it for anything.
take care,
steve
much thanks
Thanks for your kind words..
If, God forbid, the US ever reinstates the draft, I will seek to have gain the conscientious objector designation. But this is not a decision that I can make for anyone else. I have the highest respect for Christians (such as my grandfather) who, weighing these issues, have come to different conclusions about the interplay between Christian faith and military service. I can never condemn Christians who serve in the military. I want to make that very clear: that I have only the highest respect for those who have prayerfully arrived at different beliefs and who put their lives on the line for those beliefs every day.
Stay Strong Matt
Good luck and stay strong on this, Matt. I respect your decision.
From a Veteran.
Respect your courage Matt
I respect your courage Matt for taking a conscientious stand. I wish you well on this. And thank you for the reference on Gene Sharp. I've never heard of him until your post. Have you ever read Dorothy Day and her paper, the Catholic Worker? You might be interested.
Angelo
Dorothy Day
I haven't really read Dorothy Day, but I know a bit about her and the Catholic Worker movement. I was also lucky enough to be able to visit The Open Door, a Protestant house in the Catholic Worker tradition, in Atlanta.
Gene Sharp is pretty awesome, to say the least. He's one of the the leading proponents of nonviolent power theory. He also operates the Albert Einstein Institute (http://www.aeinstein.org/), which exists to spread and gain support for nonviolent ideas.